Easter Rising, Dublin, 1916

This research guide is a companion to the exhibition The Irish Rising: 'A terrible beauty is born' at State Library Victoria, 17 March–31 July 2016

Conscription plebiscites

Unlike most other countries engaged in World War I, conscription was not introduced in Australia. All the Australians who fought in World War I were volunteers. Visit the Irish in Australia tab for resources about Australia's Irish-born Anzacs.

At the outbreak of World War I in 1914, so many Australians voluntarily enlisted that men were turned away. By 1916 the scale of the slaughter was evident and the goals of the war less clear; as casualties rose, enlistments declined. Pressured by the British government to keep its regiments filled but aware of diminished public support for the war, the Australian Labor government under Prime Minister Billy Hughes floated the idea of conscription via two plebiscites held on 28 October 1916 and 20 December 1917.

Legally, the government was able to introduce conscription without this consultation, but it was aware that feelings on the issue ran high and bitterly divided the community. While many politicians favoured conscription, it was strongly opposed by many in the community.

In October 1916, the ‘no’ campaign triumphed narrowly – 1,160,033 to 1,087,557 – a result repeated at the second plebiscite in 1917.

Archbishop Mannix and the 'No' vote

Melbourne’s Archbishop Daniel Mannix was a key figure in the campaign against conscription. Born and trained in Ireland, he, like many others, did not support violent republican tactics but was radicalised by the swift executions of the Rising’s leaders in 1916 and became a fierce advocate of Irish independence. This was interpreted by many as Irish disloyalty to England and its echoes were felt throughout the 20th century: Irish-Catholic Australians were seen as disloyal citizens. Many of the Archbishop's anti-conscription speeches were reported in detail in the newspapers.

Vida Goldstein selling Votes for Women newspaper MS11749/PHO1Women & the anti-conscription movement

Other people, often women, were against war itself. An Anti-Conscription League was formed and the Women's Peace Army, a movement driven by the indomitable Vida Goldstein, mounted a fierce campaign against the war and conscription.

Labour movement

Generally the Labour movement was opposed to conscription, partly fearing the loss of men's jobs if they went to the War.  Some of the anti conscription leaflets also argued that conscription endangered the White Australia Policy.

Pro-conscriptionists

People's reasons for being either pro or anti-conscription varied. Support for conscription usually originated from a sense of loyalty to Britain, which was seen as the Motherland, outrage at Germany's attack on Belgium and France, or out of fear for Australia's safety if Britain lost the war. Women were encouraged to shame their male relatives into joining the army.

The Australian Statesman and Mining Standard was published by Critchley Parker. The issue below, Australia's real scab, is pro-conscription and highly critical of Archbishop Mannix. Critchley Parker also wrote and published The Irish rebellion and Australian opinion which presents a strongly pro-British view of the Rising.

Voice of the sainted dead, a pro- conscription poster published by the Reinforcements Referendum Council, compares Mannix's pro-Irish views unfavourably with his less outspoken predecessor as Melbourne Archbishop, Thomas Carr.

Australian Statesman and Mining Standard Voice of the Sainted Dead

Further resources

Books

  • Books on conscription
    • This is a general search for books on the topic in the Library's catalogue, and results include many pamphlets and ephemera written at the time. A large number of items have been digitised and are freely accessible by clicking the 'View online' tab beneath each digitised item.

Articles

Irish Rising Exhibition

Exhibition at State Library Victoria

17 March 2016 to 31 July 2016

Archbishop Daniel Mannix

Archbishop Mannix

Archbishop Mannix, H2011.20/78

Journal & newspaper databases

These databases include a wide range of articles from scholarly journals. They are available in the Library and can be accessed offsite by registered Victorian users.

For an Australian Irish Catholic view of the conscription plebiscites,  see articles in the the Catholic papers, The Advocate  or The Tribune (Victoria), and The Catholic Press (Sydney).

Anti-conscription poster

WM Hughes  MHR  In no circumstances

W.M. Hughes, M.H.R. " In no circumstances...", Riley & Ephemera Collection.

Poster refers to a comment made by Billy Hughes in Parliament in 1915. The date was actually 16 July 1915 not 22 July.